Janet emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders jstor. Twelfthgraders, many researchers have studied various. A year before murray gave his talk on process, janet emig published her seminal study, the composing processes of twelfth graders in which she concluded that the processes actual students used is almost nothing like the structured and linear process lined out in composition books. The roots of the process model may further be traced to dewey and others working within the progressive education movement of the early part of this. Intentions and revisions outside the writing classroom, the word revision suggests a process of. The composing process of 12th graders ncte, 1971 writing. Case study of 8 above average 12th grade students and their writing. The composing processes of twelfth graders chapter 2. Composition core reading list rationale and directions for students. David mair university of oklahoma nancy roundy iowa state university janet emigls 1971 study, the composing processes of twelfth graders, spurred an interest in the writing process. Emigking attitude scale for teachers microform janet emig and. Sophisticated work is presently going on in this area. Janet emig 1971 was the first writing researcher to use the thinkaloud method in her seminal work on the composing process of her twelfthgrade subjects. Janet emig the actual steps of the writing process, which is studied by future and practicing teachers, were formulated by janet emig, donald murray, and peter elbow.
However, because it has mostly considered only unskilled. Janet emigs the composing process of twelfth graders. Janet emigls 1971 study, the composing processes of twelfth graders, spurred. The composing processes of unskilled college writers. Though the title may mislead you to think that she did a wide survey, emigs study of the composing processes of twelfth. Based on her findings, the author suggests changes in the way composition is taught and the way teachers are trained to teach it. Based on her findings, she suggests changes in the way composition is taught and the way teachers are trained to. As you think about expanding the list according to your areas. One focuses on the behavior a writer exhibits in completing a writing task. The case study used methods such as protocol analysis, taperecorded interviews, and discourse analysis. The composing processes of twelfth graders janet a. Emigs was the first significant study of student composing processes, giving impetus to the consciousness of writing as process.
The methodology section is not as robust as what we are used to today, but it is thorough. Reassessing janet emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders. The seminal work of process model pedagogy, janet emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders, published in 1969, opens with a description of the available data sources for the researcher concerned with the composing process. The nature, development, and teaching of written composition. Schreiner revisits key implications of janet emigs use of literary authorship in her composing process scholarship. This inquiry examines the composing process of twelfth grade writers, using a case study method. We approach the composing process from two perspectives. Flowers analyses of thinking aloud protocols, verbal descriptions of what writers report they think and do while they compose.
Duggans sced 315 class and i thought it would be interesting to look into some of her work. Since emigs encounters with lynn form the heart of her study harris 82, i will do a close reading of. Janet emig3 landmark study, the composing processes of twelfth graders, revolutionized composition theory and practice. Emig s was the first significant study of student composing processes, giving impetus to the consciousness of writing as process that prevails in todays composition theory and pedagogy. Although emig first suggested it, flower and hayes and their collaborators have done most to demonstrate the recur. Composing process research was pioneered by scholars such as janet emig in the composing processes of twelfth graders, sondra perl in the composing processes of unskilled college writers, and linda flower and john r. The composing process of twelth graders by janet emig sadie anderson results of study viewed as first significant study of student composing processes new teaching methodsclaims about teachers being illiterate. Ed058205 the composing processes of twelfth graders. The composing processes of twelfth graders book, 1971.
The composing processes of twelfth graders by janet emig prezi. The development of writing abilities 1118 by james britton and his colleagues. Janet emigs 1971 report, the composing process of twelfth graders, documented the bland and dutiful approaches even the most highachieving and ambitious of students took when they worked on assigned writing. Conclusions the composing processes of twelfth graders. The composing processes of twelfth graders, ncte research report no. The composing processes of twelfth graders by janet emig. Research on the writing process sometimes called the composing process focuses on how writers draft, revise, and edit texts.
Reviews emig s methodology, highlighting both the timeliness of her study, and the flaws in her generalizations about writing teachers expertise. Already in 1982, janet emig, author of the groundbreaking book, composing processes of twelfth graders, called into question the theory and methodology of early process research. Janet emig reports on a case study in which eight twelfth graders were asked to give autobiographies of their writing experiences and to compose aloud in the presence of the investigator. I found the composing processes of twelfth graders on a shelf in the library and i knew i had to read this book. They view the composing process as a series of decisionmaking strategies.
Cautions against depending upon her results and those of similar studies, as the final word on the writing process. The second example is janet emigs 1971 study of the composing process of a group of twelfth graders. Janet emig the composing process of twelfth graders, 1971 is a clear example central problem involves selfimage have not recognized and claimed potential methodological authority concerned with what is uniqueparticular to some unit within a population, but bring larger population to bear. The composing approach popularized the process approach to writing, adding emphasis to not just the text them selves, but the production of texts. Assessments of recent research, new research, applications in the classroom. Reviews emigs methodology, highlighting both the timeliness of her study, and the flaws in her generalizations about writing teachers expertise. In retrospect, it is apparent that the empirical methodology of early process. A curricular history 2nd editionsouthern illinois up, 2002 isbn 9780809324675 ball, cheryl, and drew loewe eds. Emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders and other publications of the late 1960s and early 1970s made the point that a strictly grammatical approach to writing did not reflect the way. However, a survey of current literature indicates that littie has been published on the composing processes of technical writers. The composing processes of twelfth graders by janet a. Based on janet emigs breakdown of the writing process, the process is centered on the idea that students determine the content of the course by exploring the craft of writing using their own interests, language, techniques, voice. Improving writing in the classroom summer session, 1981 instructor. As one of the first major research publications in the teaching of writing, janet emigs study offers compelling ideas on research methodology particularly using composing aloud protocols and research analysis.
As one of the first major research publications in the teaching of writing, janet emig s study offers compelling ideas on research methodology particularly using composing aloud protocols and research analysis. Feminine principles and womens experience in american composition and rhetoric louise wetherbee phelp. Nelson also uses sections from previous work to maintain his point in a document with the faithful company. In the composing process of twelfth graders 1971, she writing as a cognitive. The composing processes of unskilled college writers sondra perl herbert h. Emig is known for her works on the writing process and one of her famous books is the composing processes of twelfth graders where she works to outline the major writing processes. The core list is designed to introduce you to the intersection of history, theory, research, and practice in composition studies. Selzer mentioning the composing process of twelfth graders and research of composing by authors janet emig, cooper and odell demonstrates this credibility, or ethos. This inquiry examines the composing process of twelfthgrade writers, using a case study method. The composing processes of twelfth graders microform.
This classic studybuilt out of emigs dissertationis considered by many to be a crucial first touchstone for empirical research in written composition. In 1971, emig illuminated the contradictions between what. The composing processes of twelfth graders microform janet emig distributed by eric clearinghouse washington, d. Since janet emig over a decade ago investigated the composing processes of. Janet emig 3 landmark study, the composing processes of twelfth graders, revolutionized composition theory and practice.
As students of all ages have been shown to with some of the accounts of the creative prohave elements, moments, and stages. Composing processes of twelfth graders, the ncte store. Mode of analysis the purpose of this chapter is to delineate dimensions of the composing process among secondary school students, against which case studies of twelfthgrade writers can be analyzed. Her ethnographic case study of eight student writers provided evidence that composing should be viewed as a process, that students and their teachers should write frequently and in a.
Hayes, a cognitiveprocess theory of writing, college composition and communication 32 1981. This classic studybuilt out of emigs dissertationis. Janet emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders. Reassessing janet emigs the composing process of twelfth graders. Janet emigls 1971 study, the composing processes of twelfth graders, spurred an interest in the writing process.
Her first monograph, the composing processes of twelfth graders, a slight. These investigations employ different methods, terminology, and numbers of subjects, but. Her ethnographic case study of eight student writers provided evidence that composing should be viewed as a process, that students and. In this study, emig seeks to answer the question of what happens to the self as a result educational stimuli in terms of academic writing. College composition and communication, v34 n3 p27883 oct 1983. The composing processes of twelfth graders, issue issue of ncte research report, issn 00853739 ncte research reports, no. Looking back at table 1, we see that janet emigs the composing processes of twelfth graders is the most frequently cited text in this chapter and provides the framework for another one of harris key ideas. In 1973, as part of my doctoral studies, i read janet emigs groundbreaking study,the composing processes of twelfth graders. Stephen north, the making of knowledge in composition.
Her work struck me immediately as important, forwardlooking, and relevant to our concerns at cuny. About twelve years have passed since the publication of the composing pro cesses of twelfthgraders, janet emigs study of how eight seniors from six. Janet emig reports on a case study in which eight twelfth graders were asked to give autobiographies of their writing experiences and to compose aloud in the. About twelve years have passed since the publication of the composing processes of twelfthgraders, janet emigs study of how eight seniors from six chicago area high schools approached certain composition tasks. Here are the nitpicky details on the students who participated. Studies in writers block and other composiing process problems. The composing processes of an engineer jack seizer since janet emig over a decade ago investigated the composing processes of twelfthgraders, many researchers have studied various aspects of writers composing habits. Lehman college of the city university of new york this paper presents the pertinent findings from a study of the composing processes of five unskilled college writers perl, 1978. The composing process of twelth graders by janet emig prezi. It was obvious to me that those of us teaching writing on cuny campuses had no understanding of how our students wrote. The composing processes of an engineer semantic scholar. Eight twelfth graders were asked, in four sessions, each, to give autobiographies of their writing experiences and to compose aloud three times in the presence of a tape recorder and an investigator. The composing process of 12th graders ncte, 1971 isbn 9780814108031 russell, david. The design of the study this chapter, as noted, is how the study on the writing processes of 12th graders was designed.
955 1437 324 828 272 475 619 1086 1274 1239 779 1011 134 1577 69 560 1586 754 1300 1626 1167 419 1628 683 875 1356 128 1295 978 756 368 447 603 582 1072 104 143 80 1487 1457 93 739 1329 967 360 294 413